“Shirk” in Qasida Burdah? Yasir Qadhi’s Repugnant Attack.

 

(Picture: Maqaam of Imam Busiri, Allah bless him
abundantly for his beautiful poem, Al-Burdah)

YASIR QADHI ATTACKS AL-BURDAH

Yasir Qadhi accused the famous and beautiful Qasida Burdah by Imam Busiri (Allah bless him) as being filled with shirk. This is no surprise, of course. He, like other confused Wahhabis, loyally follow the footsteps of the founder of the Wahhabi movement, Muhammad ibn `Abdal-Wahhab, who, according to Shaykh GF Haddad, noted this in the infamous and unscholarly Kitab al-Tawhid:

“Equating the poem al-Burda to setting up an equal to Allah SWT”

(Source: http://www.livingislam.org/wahtwd_e.html)

Of the al-Burdah, Yasir Qadhi said:

Yes, there is much in the poem that is praiseworhty and beautiful. In fact, certain sections will even move you to tears.

However, that doesn’t change the fact that there is blatant shirk in all three categories of tahweed in that poem: shrik in ruboobiyyah, uloohiyyah and asma wa sifaat.

Therefore, the poem should not and cannot be read except to correct these exceses.

As for the alleged story of how the poem was written, the Prophet (saw) would not appear to anyone and praise him had he written soemthing of shirk. It is only the mystics who base their religion on dreams and fairy-tales; as for the true Muslm, he has the Quran and authentic Sunnah as his only true guides.

BTW, just so no one things I haven’t read the poem or am passing judgments w/o any knoweldge:

An example of shirk in ruboobiyyah is the stanza:
“And of your generosity is the (creation) of the Wolrd and its co-wife (meaning the Hereafter)…” Here it is as if the World and the Hereafter was created from the generosity of the Prophet (SAW).

An example of Shirk in Asma wa sifaat:
“And part of your knowledge is the knowlege of the Tablet and the Pen…” So PART of the knowledge of the Prophet (SAW) is the knoewledge that is encompassed in the LAwh al-Mahufdh – the tablet that has EVERYTHING written on it!! and that is only ‘part’ of his knowledge!! Compare this mystic poem with the authentic hadeeth in Bukhari where a young girl said “And we have a prophet who knows what will happen tommorrow.’ to which the Prophet (SAW) said, “Leave this (bit), and say the rest of it.”

Example of shirk in uloohiyyah:
” And who else there, besides you, who I can call out, at times of distress and problems?” Umm… how about our Creator, the only one the Prophet (SAW) HIMSELF would turn to at times of distress??

The poem is a prime example of over-praising the Prophet (SAW) and putting him ina place where even he himself would not like. We will discuss it more in Aqeedah 101 insha Allah.

Yasir

(Source: http://forums.almaghrib.org/showpost.php?p=381421&postcount=6)

IMAM HAMZA YUSUF & SHAYKH ABDAL HAKIM MURAD PRAISE
AL-BURDAH

  Before giving the refutation against Yasir Qadhi’s (mis) understanding – which is devoid of Islamic intellectual depth or correct understanding – it is worth seeing and listening to the short documentary on youtube on Qasida al-Burdah in which Imam Hamza Yusuf, Shaykh Abdal Hakim Murad, and poet Daniel Moore discuss the immense value and inspiring story of Imam al-Busiri and his beloved poem. The documentary is at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o_dOTPWN2-s
Imam Hamza
Yusuf

SHAYKH FARAZ RABBANI RESPONDS

Yasir Qadhi was soundly refuted by Shaykh Faraz Rabbani, a traditional Sunni scholar of the Hanafi madhab, who explained in detail how Yasir had completely missed the point. Shaykh Rabbani is a former instructor at the Sunnipath Academy (www.sunnipath.com) and is currently leading Seekers Guidance (http://seekersguidance.org). Had Yasir read what the author of the poem meant, he would not have relied on his own misleading interpretations of the certain poetic verses he refers to. It is strange that Yasir neglected to do his homework and was willing to conclude and accuse a respected Muslim of shirk. Yasir also contradicts the overwhelming majority of scholars from the Hanafi, Shafi’i, Maliki, and Hanbali madhahib, who  have never hated such a poem, much less accused its author of blatant shirk. Rather, they embraced the poem for its beauty, eloquence, and deep spiritual meaning. Allah’s blessings for this poem are evident as it has been recited and sung in all parts of the world from Africa to the Middle East to South Asia to Southeast Asia. 

Now, let’s read what Shaykh Rabbani says:

In the Name of Allah, Most Merciful and Compassionate

May Allah’s peace and blessings be upon His Beloved Messenger Muhammad, his noble folk, righteous companions, and all followers.

No, the Qasida Burda doesn’t contain “shirk” (associating partners with Allah) or other deviations from sound Islamic belief. Rather, it is a pure expression of deep and passionate love for the Beloved Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him), whose love is a condition of faith.

The Qasida Burda has been accepted by the mainstream of Islamic scholarship as one of the greatest statements of love for the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him). It is recited across the Muslim world, from East to West, as it has been for centuries. There are dozens of commentaries on it, by many of the greatest scholars of Islam, none of whom saw any “blatant shirk” in its beautiful praise of the Beloved Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him). However, given its eloquence and depth, certain verses-such as those criticized by our respected critic-need to be understood as the author meant them. It is unfair to interpret others’ words in ways they did not mean.

[1] The critic cites the opening of the verse as an example of “shirk” in the Oneness of Allah’s Lordship (tawhid al-rububiyya):

“From our generosity is the world and its partner [the Hereafter]…”

Our respected critic claims that this refers to the creation of the world and there hereafter-as if Busiri is claiming that the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) and his generosity created them! The Arabic text if this verse doesn’t mention “creation” in it.

As Imam Ibrahim al-Bajuri makes clear in his commentary on the Burda, what this means is that the best of this world and the next is from the gift the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) gave-by Allah’s granting-to humanity.

The best of this world is the guidance of the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him), by which alone this worldly has any meaning; and the best gift of any human to humanity in the Hereafter is the intercession the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) makes-as established in rigorously authentic hadiths, as we will see below.

There is a basic principle in knowledge that, “Ruling on a matter comes after sound understanding of it.” To criticize someone’s words, one must first soundly understand them as the author intended them-not as one’s own understanding determines.

[2] The critic then cites the following verses as example of shirk in Allah’s Names & Attributes,

“And from your knowledge is knowledge of the Pen and Tablet”

It is established that Allah commanded the Pen to write the details of all matters until the Last Day-namely, before the Resurrection and Hereafter-as related in authentic hadiths in Ahmad and Tirmidhi. These hadiths were considered mass-transmitted by al-Amir al-Kabir in his commentary on Laqani’s Jawharat al-Tawhid, as Kattani relates in Nadhm al-Mutanathir.

In this hadith, the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) said, “The first of Allah’s creation was the pen.” Then he mentioned that Allah commanded it to, “Write everything that will occur, until the Last Hour.” [Ahmad 21649, from Ubada ibn Samit (Allah be pleased with him)]

It is authentically established that Allah granted His Beloved Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) knowledge of the events of this worldly life.

There is no “shirk” in this: (1) it is authentically established in the sunna; (2) it is by Allah’s granting, so there is no point of comparison between the Absolute, Infinite, and unacquired Knowledge of Allah and the acquired, and limited (though inimaginably vast) knowledge of the Best of Creation (Allah bless him and give him peace).

The knowledge of the Pen and Tablet-being this knowledge of worldly events until the Last Day-is “from” the knowledge of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) because he was also granted tremendous knowledge of matters of the hereafter, and of Allah and His Attributes-the greatest of all knowledge.

What we need to understand is that Allah granted His Beloved Messenger (Allah bless him and give him peace) tremendous knowledge of the Unseen, including details of matters of this life and the next; and He granted His Beloved (Allah bless him and give him peace) greater knowledge of Himself than any of His creation.

Thus, there is no element of shirk in this verse. It simply affirms what the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) himself affirmed, not more and not less.

[3] Our respected critic then cites the following verse as an example of “shirk” in Allah’s Oneness in Divinity (tawhid al-uluhiyya):

” And who else there, besides you, who I can call out, at times of distress and problems?”

This is our critic’s suggested translation. A sounder translation is:

“O Most Honored of Creation! Whom can I turn to

But you when the Encompassing Event befalls?”

The “Encompassing Event” (wrongly translated us “times of distress and problems”) refers specifically to the distress that befalls all creation on the Day of Resurrection. As authentic hadiths in Bukhari [3092], Muslim [287], and elsewhere affirm, all of creation will go from one prophet to another, each of whom is busy with themselves-out of absolute awe of Allah-and tells them to go to another prophet. Finally, all of creation goes to our Beloved Messenger (Allah bless him and give him peace), seeking respite from the tremendous tribulation and distress of that Day. The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) answers their call, affirming that this is from what Allah granted him, and turns to Allah seeking respite for creation, and this is granted to him by Allah.

There is no suggestion in this verse that a believer shouldn’t turn to Allah Himself when distress and problems occur. Rather, it is simply affirming something the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) affirmed: that Allah has granted His Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) general intercession for all creation from the intensity of the tribulations of the Day of Judgment, and that on that Day all creation will find none in creation to turn to for assistance but Allah’s Beloved (Allah bless him and give him peace).

This also shows that seeking the assistance of creation-whether in material or spiritual matters-does in no way negate one’s understanding that Allah alone is the ultimate granter. But our Giving Lord has shown us that there are both material and spiritual means one seeks, while fully aware that the Giver and Granter is none but Allah.

This is the aqida of the mainstream of Muslims: we affirm the taking of material and spiritual means, and affirm that the granter is only Allah Himself. This is the understanding of the great Companion of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), Rabi`ah ibn Ka`b al-Aslami (Allah be pleased with him), who said, “O Messenger of Allah! I ask you for your company in Paradise!” The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) replied, “Assist me concerning yourself with much prostration.” [Muslim (754)]

[ref: The commentaries on Busiri’s Burda by Bajuri, Hamzawi, Ibn Hajar, and Shaykh Zada]

And Allah alone gives success.

Faraz Rabbani

(Source: http://qa.sunnipath.com/issue_view.asp?id=11961)

SHAYKH WAHBA AL-ZUHAYLI’S
RESPONSE TO THE IGNORANT

The poem states:

“[O most generous of creation,] who but you can I turn to When the Universal Cataclysm occurs?…”

Shaykh al-Zuhayli explains:

“The first line contains faith and affirmation of the Prophet’s intercession (pbuh). His intercession is two types: the greater  intercession for all of the creation in being relieved of the terrors of the standing and going forward to their accounts and the second intercession for the disobedient among the Muslims.” 

The poem states:

“From your largess flows the good of this world and its counterpart in the next, And from your knowledge is knowledge of the Tablet and the Pen…”

Shaykh al-Zuhayli explains:

“The second line does not imply independent creation and bringing into existence, rather, it means that that the bounty of the this world and the next is through faith in the message of the greatest Messenger (pbuh). As for what is meant by knowledge here, it refers to the knowledge that Allah taught him via revelation only, and not peering into the matters of the unseen that were not learned through the revelation.”

The poem states:

“By the pre-eminance of the one whose house is in the Pure Land, And whose name is an oath among the greatest of oaths” 

 

Shaykh al-Zuhayli explains: 

“The meaning of the third line is that Allah swore an oath by the Prophet when He said: “And by your life, they are blind in their drunkenness.” 

After warning from this [incorrect] understanding, I warn from the confusion of the confused and taking advantage of the foolish ones who do not understand al-Busiri’s intent or that of others. We are the most keen of people in having sound doctrine; the ill understanding of the ignorant will not harm us the least.”

(Source: http://marifah.net/articles/burdah-alzuhayli.pdf)    

Advertisements

4 responses to ““Shirk” in Qasida Burdah? Yasir Qadhi’s Repugnant Attack.

  1. “If you differ in anything among yourselves, refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you believe in Allah and the Last Day. That is best and most commendable in the end” [4:59]

    Also, He says:

    “And whatever you disagree upon, its decision is with Allah” [42:10]

    So, is the Burdah from the Quran or Sunnah?.

    Can you outdo the companions in your love for the Prophet sal’Allah’hu’alaihi’wasalam? Can you do better than Abu Bakar and Umar? Well then, why don’t you just stick to their way? …Isn’t it safer to stick with the earliest generation and how they love the Prophet sal’Allah’hu’alaihi’wasalam? With so much controversial, isn’t it safer to just stick with Abu Bakar, Umar, Ali, Imam Bukhari, Imam Muslim did it? And you know how they did it? They followed the Sunnah of the Prophet sal’Allah’hu’alaihiwasalam.

    No need to argue anymore, and no need to label anyone anymore. What’s the point anyway…

    • please interpret this ayat, wa auha, ila abdihi ma yuha during isra i of the prophet. don’t comment on what you have limited knowledge of

  2. Pingback: Muslim Matters opposes Shaykh Abdal Hakim Murad « ~ Yasir Qadhi UNVEILED ~

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s